Board book or hardcover? For toddlers, board usually wins

Hardcovers can be beautiful, but toddlers are not gentle archivists. Board books are built for lap reading, floor reading, page grabbing, and the fifth request for one more time.

Start their book: upload the photo, see a free preview

What a board book actually is

Every page is a slab of chipboard, a sixteenth of an inch thick in TinyStar's case, laminated so it wipes clean, with rounded corners so nobody gets poked. There is no dust jacket to lose and no paper to tear. A toddler can turn the pages alone, which is the point: at eighteen months, turning the page is the fun part.

What a hardcover is good at

More pages, bigger pages, finer detail in the art, and a spine that looks right on a shelf. For a child of four or five who has stopped chewing books and started following plots, a hardcover picture book is a fine gift. It is also fragile in exactly the ways a toddler tests: thin paper, corners that dent, a jacket that is gone within the week.

Why the personalized version should be board

A personalized book is the one they will ask for most, because it has their face in it. That makes it the book that takes the most abuse. Printing it as a hardcover means the most-loved book in the house is also the most likely to be in pieces by the second birthday. Printing it as a board book means it survives to be read at the third one.

An inside spread of a personalized board book

The trade-off, honestly

A board book has fewer pages. TinyStar's is 20 pages: ten illustrated spreads plus covers, 6 by 6 inches. That is a story, not a novel, and for ages one to three that is correct. A one year old's attention is about eight pages long. A longer book is not more book, it is a book that never gets finished.

When to choose which

Under four: board book, no contest. Four to six: still board if it is going to be a bedtime regular, since regulars get worn out; hardcover if it is a shelf book for occasional reading. TinyStar prints board books only, for ages one to six, and offers a digital PDF if you want a version to read on a tablet or print at home.

What is in the personalized board book, page by page. Board book versus storybook, the simple version.

Questions parents ask

Is TinyStar a hardcover book?

No. TinyStar's primary printed product is a personalized board book, not a hardcover picture book.

How many pages does the board book have?

20 pages: ten illustrated story spreads plus a front cover with the child's name and a back cover, 6 by 6 inches.

Which format for a four or five year old?

Board if it will be a bedtime regular, since regulars get worn out. A hardcover picture book suits a child who has stopped chewing books and reads occasionally.

Start their book: upload the photo, see a free preview